Many landlords struggle with properly handling security deposit deductions while staying compliant with North Carolina tenant-landlord laws.
Most landlords require tenants to pay for a security deposit where they can deduct unpaid rent, excessive cleaning costs, and tenant-caused damage—but only if they follow the correct legal process. Failing to provide an itemized list of security deposit deductions could result in disputes, financial losses, or legal action. Without a clear grasp of these rules, you risk facing small claims court battles, bad reviews, or accusations of bad faith deductions.
In this guide, we’ll help you gain the knowledge to handle security deposits confidently while avoiding unnecessary disputes.
Greenville, North Carolina Laws on Security Deposits
Generally, landlords can’t just keep the full security deposit without cause. Every deduction must be justified, documented, and itemized. In North Carolina, landlords must:
- Store the security deposit in a trust account or get a bond.
- Return any remaining deposit funds within 30 days of the tenant moving out.
- Provide an itemized list of deductions for any withheld amount.
Failure to comply could result in legal action—including small claims court battles and potential penalties.
What Landlords Can Deduct from a Security Deposit?
Handling security deposit deductions can be a sensitive issue. While tenants expect to get their full security deposit back, landlords must ensure they aren't left covering unpaid rent, property damage, or excessive cleaning costs. The key is understanding what’s fair and legal and what’s considered normal wear and tear versus tenant-caused damage.
Here’s a detailed breakdown of what you can legally deduct from a security deposit as a landlord in Greenville, NC:
1. Unpaid Rent, Late Fees, and Unpaid Utilities
A tenant’s security deposit serves as a financial safety net, especially if they fail to pay rent or leave outstanding bills, such as:
- If a tenant leaves before paying their last month’s rent.
- If your lease agreement allows late fees and the tenant hasn’t paid them.
- If the tenant was responsible for utilities (electricity, water, gas, etc.) and left an unpaid bill.
Exceptions: If the rental agreement states that last month’s rent was pre-paid, you cannot use the security deposit for it. Also, if utility bills were in your name and not explicitly stated in the lease as the tenant’s responsibility, you might be unable to deduct them.
2. Property Damage Beyond Normal Wear and Tear
Every rental unit experiences normal wear and tear, but landlords can deduct repair costs when a tenant damages the property beyond that. Examples of deductible tenant-caused damage are:
- Broken windows, doors, or locks (from negligence or misuse).
- Holes in walls (beyond small nail holes for hanging pictures).
- Burn marks, stains, or pet damage on carpets.
- Damaged appliances (e.g., a broken fridge handle, oven door, or washing machine).
- Water damage from improper use (e.g., a tenant let a leak go unchecked, causing floor damage).
- Broken light fixtures, missing smoke detectors, or cracked tiles.
Pro tip: Conducting before-and-after inspections ensures you have proof if deductions are challenged.
3. Cleaning Costs and Professional Cleaning Fees
A rental property doesn’t have to be perfectly spotless when a tenant moves out, but it does need to be reasonably clean. If a tenant leaves the unit in a filthy condition, landlords can deduct for cleaning fees. Examples of these are:
- Excessive dirt, grime, or trash left behind.
- Mold, pet odors, or cigarette smoke damage.
- Pest infestations due to tenant negligence (e.g., a cockroach infestation caused by unclean conditions).
- Heavy grease buildup in the kitchen.
- Disposal costs for abandoned furniture or belongings.
4. Repair and Maintenance Costs
Landlords deduct repairs that result from tenant neglect or abuse but not for general maintenance that happens over time. Some of the repairs that you can deduct are:
- Replacing a broken toilet seat, sink, or showerhead if the damage was due to misuse.
- Fixing large holes or excessive scuffs in walls.
- Repairing damaged countertops or cabinets.
- Replacing blinds or curtains if they are broken or missing.
- Fixing a broken air conditioning or heating system if the damage was caused by tenant neglect.
Pro tip: Always get a detailed repair invoice and attach it to the itemized list of security deposit deductions.
5. Abandoned Furniture and Trash Removal Costs
Landowners can deduct the disposal costs if a tenant leaves behind large furniture, trash, or personal belongings. For instance, you can deduct large items like sofas, mattresses, or dressers left behind. Excessive trash or clutter that requires removal and hauling fees for abandoned belongings are also considered deductible.
Creating an Itemized List of Security Deposit Deductions
A security deposit isn’t just a financial safety net for landlords—it’s also a legal responsibility. If you deduct from a security deposit, you must follow North Carolina’s tenant-landlord laws, which require detailed documentation and an itemized list of deductions.
Here’s how to properly document and itemize deductions to protect your rental property while complying with the law:
Perform a Move-Out Inspection
Before making any deductions, you must inspect the rental unit and gather evidence of damage, unpaid rent, or excessive cleaning needs. Rental inspection reports ensure fair deductions and protect yourself if a tenant disputes the charges.
Break Down the Costs in an Itemized List
Once the inspection is complete, landlords must create a clear, detailed, and itemized receipt outlining exactly what is being deducted and why. For each deduction, describe the issue (e.g., “Carpet replacement due to pet urine stains”). Don’t also forget to include the cost of the repair, cleaning, or unpaid rent amount.
It’s also important to document receipts, invoices, or estimates from vendors, cleaning companies, or maintenance professionals and clearly explain why the deduction is justified.
Provide a Written Notice with the Itemized List
North Carolina law requires landlords to return the remaining security deposit (if any) and provide an itemized list of deductions within 30 days of the tenant vacating. Send a written notice with the itemized list of deductions, including a check or payment receipt for any remaining deposit funds. Then, mail or email the notice to the tenant’s forwarding address (if provided) and keep a copy of the notice and receipts for your records.
Important Note: If the tenant did not provide a forwarding address, landlords can send the notice to the tenant’s last known address (the rental property itself).
Ensure Legal Compliance When Deducting from a Security Deposit
Security deposit deductions can be challenging for landlords, but with the right approach, you can minimize disputes and stay compliant with North Carolina’s laws. The key is maintaining detailed records, conducting thorough inspections, and communicating openly with tenants.
At Flagship Realty Group, we take the stress out of security deposit management by ensuring that every step of the process is handled legally, fairly, and efficiently. Our expert property managers in Greenville, NC, assist landlords with:
- Comprehensive move-in and move-out inspections to document property conditions.
- Itemized entire security deposit deductions backed by clear reports, receipts, and legal compliance.
- Tenant communication and dispute resolution to prevent legal issues and ensure smooth transitions.
- Full-service property management, including rent collection, lease enforcement, and maintenance coordination.
Don’t let security deposit disputes become a hassle. Let Flagship Realty Group handle the details while you focus on growing your rental property business. Check out our services to learn how our property management experts can save you time, money, and unnecessary stress!
Related Articles
How to Manage Property Maintenance at Your Greenville, NC Properties
Do Property Managers Pay for Repairs in Greenville, NC?
Best Practices for Rent Collection: Top 4 Tips for Goldsboro, NC Landlords
